OPINION- By: Kebour Ghenna
Ethiopia has problems (nothing new!).
War. Displacement. Unemployment. Inflation. Poverty. Debt. Young people wondering whether their future lies somewhere beyond the country’s borders.
Fortunately, we have found something else to argue about.
Who gets Addis Ababa?
For years, Ethiopia’s National Dialogue Commission traveled across the country and consulted Ethiopians abroad. Thousands of people were mobilized. Eventually, some 4,000 delegates gathered in Addis Ababa to discuss the country’s future.
And among the great questions of the Ethiopian future is apparently the ownership and status of Addis Ababa.
The Commission’s agenda is remarkably detailed. It includes the city’s legal status, its relationship with Oromia, its boundaries, language, police, courts, heritage, and its status as the federal capital.
All legitimate constitutional questions. But there is a danger hiding inside the question itself.
When did a national capital become something for one group to win and another to lose?
A city built by a country
Addis Ababa did not become Addis Ababa because one government built it.
Generations built it. People arrived from every corner of Ethiopia. They traded there. Worked there. Paid taxes there. Raised children there. Built businesses there. Swept its streets, constructed its buildings, taught in its schools, staffed its hospitals, and filled its markets.
Whatever its geography and complicated history, modern Addis Ababa is the accumulated work of Ethiopians.
That should matter.
A national capital can certainly sit geographically within a regional state. Constitutional arrangements can recognize regional interests.
Oromia has legitimate historical, geographic, cultural and economic interests concerning the city that deserve serious treatment.
But recognition is one thing. Political possession is another.
The moment the discussion becomes “Whose city is it?”, we have already travelled down a dangerous road. Because Ethiopia has many peoples. And many cities.
If Addis Ababa becomes understood politically as the achievement of one group’s struggle, an obvious question follows. What do the others get?
If Addis Ababa is understood as something one region has gained, what principle follows for everyone else?
What should the other regions now seek: a city, a federal institution, a special territorial claim of their own?
This is where the logic becomes dangerous. A federation cannot become a marketplace in which national assets are divided among competing identities until everyone feels compensated. Once politics is organized around the question of “What did our group get?”, every settlement creates the demand for another settlement.
The better question is not what Oromia gets, or what the other regions should receive in return. It is what Ethiopians possess together that should never become the political property of any one group.
A national capital should surely be one of those things. In fact, a country cannot build national unity by distributing pieces of the nation among competing identities.
The Bern comparison
One may point to Bern.
Bern is the seat of Switzerland’s federal government and simultaneously the capital of the Canton of Bern.
Fine.
But Switzerland did not arrive at that arrangement by asking which ethnic constituency had finally “won” Bern. The arrangement operates within a political culture built around strong local government, federal compromise, citizenship, institutional restraint, and rules accepted across communities.
The lesson from Switzerland is therefore not that two governments can occupy the same city.
Of course they can.
The lesson is that constitutional architecture works only when citizens trust the architecture.
If Addis Ababa is to accommodate both federal and Oromia institutions, the real question should therefore not be who has gained the city. It should be: What guarantees make Addis Ababa genuinely belong to every citizen who lives there and every Ethiopian for whom it is the national capital?
That requires far more than changing an administrative label. It requires elected and accountable city government. Transparent land administration. Equal treatment irrespective of ethnicity. Protection against politically directed demographic or property manipulation.
It also requires clear fiscal arrangements. Independent courts. Transparent zoning and compensation. Protection of historical and cultural heritage. Equal access to public employment and services. And, above everything else, the right of the city’s residents to have a decisive voice in how their city is governed.
Without those guarantees, constitutional ingenuity will solve very little.
Was the answer waiting before the question?
There is another uncomfortable issue.
The battle over Addis Ababa began long before the National Dialogue. Competing claims over the city did not suddenly appear when delegates entered the conference hall.
That created an important burden for the dialogue.
If an outcome closely resembles a political objective advocated by powerful actors long before the consultation began, citizens are entitled to ask the following:
Did the dialogue produce the conclusion, or did it provide legitimacy for a conclusion already traveling in that direction?
That question should not be dismissed as cynicism. The Commission itself says that national dialogue should produce a shared destiny rather than winners and losers.
Good.
Then Addis Ababa provides perhaps the most important test of that proposition. Because if one community leaves believing, “We got Addis Ababa,” while another leaves believing, “They took Addis Ababa,” there has been no national settlement. There has merely been a transfer of grievance.
Meanwhile, life continues
And here we arrive at the strangest part of the story.
While politicians debate who administratively possesses Addis Ababa, ordinary Ethiopians continue doing what they did yesterday.
They look for work. Pay rent. Buy increasingly expensive food. Search for medicine. Try to keep businesses alive. Worry about their children.
They did not fight for Addis Ababa. They are trying to live in it.
Perhaps that is why political elites and ordinary citizens sometimes appear to inhabit different countries. One debates ownership of the capital. The other wonders whether he can afford to remain there. One discusses constitutional symbolism. The other calculates the price of teff. One seeks historical recognition. The other seeks employment.
Which of these constitutes the greater national emergency?
Proud, dignified, and free?
A national dialogue should ultimately leave people feeling something larger than the satisfaction of having their grievance recorded. It should leave them feeling that the country belongs to them.
All of them.
One recalls the powerful idea of a people emerging from political struggle feeling proud, dignified, and once more free.
That is a high standard.
Could Ethiopians leave this dialogue feeling that way? Could an Oromo Ethiopian say “Addis Ababa is mine without meaning it is less yours? Could an Amhara, Gurage, Somali, Tigrayan, Sidama, Afar, or any other Ethiopian say exactly the same thing?
Could the resident of Addis Ababa say, “This city belongs neither to an ethnicity nor to a political party”? It belongs to its citizens and serves the Republic.
That would be something worth celebrating.
Perhaps Ethiopia needs an idea that has become unfashionable in the age of competing identities: the one and indivisible republic.
Not indivisible because diversity is denied.
Indivisible because citizenship stands above possession.
Regions can govern themselves. Cultures can flourish. Languages can prosper. Communities can preserve their identities. But there must remain certain things that we refuse to divide into ethnic property. The national capital should surely be one of them.
The wrong victory
If Oromia’s legitimate relationship with Addis Ababa is better recognized, that need not diminish anyone. But if the outcome is celebrated as Oromia getting Addis Ababa, Ethiopia will have gained very little. Because tomorrow another region will reasonably ask:
And what do we get?
That is how nations become bargaining tables. Everybody arrives with a claim. Everybody expects compensation. Nobody leaves with a country.
The challenge for the National Dialogue was supposed to be larger than this.
Not to determine which group gets what. But to help Ethiopians rediscover what belongs to all of them.
Addis Ababa could still become an extraordinary symbol of that possibility: a city with a special relationship to Oromia, a home to its residents, the seat of the federal government, and a capital in which every Ethiopian possesses equal civic dignity.
But that requires a philosophy larger than ownership. It requires citizenship. Because the question that should matter is not:
Who got Addis Ababa?
It is: What kind of Addis Ababa did Ethiopians get?”
A fair city? A transparent city? A democratic city? A prosperous city? A city where land is not political currency? A city where belonging does not depend on ethnicity? A city worthy of being the capital of a diverse country?
Those would be victories.
Everything else risks being another political settlement presented as national progress. And Ethiopia already has plenty of those
Editor’s Note: The view and opinion expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Ethiopia Today.