OPINION
By: Kebour Ghenna
There is good news coming from the National Bank of Ethiopia.
Inflation is heading toward single digits. The gap between the official and parallel exchange rates is expected to narrow. Foreign-exchange reserves have improved. Banks are becoming stronger. The financial system is being modernized.
The governor has reason to be pleased. The numbers are beginning to behave.
Unfortunately, the economy is not made of numbers.
It is made of people who work, produce, buy, sell, borrow, save and occasionally wonder why their money buys less than it used to.
And therein lies the difficulty.
The National Bank may soon be able to announce that inflation has fallen below 10 percent.
Wonderful!
A loaf of bread that became expensive last year will now become more expensive at a slower rate!
The housewife should presumably celebrate. Perhaps she could frame the inflation report and hang it above the kitchen table.
Central bankers have a peculiar occupation.
They cannot grow wheat. They cannot manufacture shoes. They cannot repair a factory, train an engineer or build a functioning export industry.
But they can influence the price and availability of money.
This is important work.
Without monetary stability, businesses struggle to plan, savers lose confidence and households suffer from unpredictable price increases.
A competent central bank can help prevent these problems. What it cannot do is turn monetary stability into prosperity by proclamation.
The distinction is worth remembering, particularly when central bankers begin sounding like ministers of economic development.
The National Bank can tighten credit. It cannot guarantee that the remaining credit reaches productive enterprises.
It can liberalize the foreign-exchange market. It cannot guarantee that Ethiopia produces enough exports to earn the foreign exchange it needs.
It can encourage stronger banks. It cannot guarantee that those banks will finance a small manufacturer rather than a large property transaction.
It can regulate financial institutions. It cannot make an unproductive economy productive.
There are limits to monetary policy.
They are not minor limits. They are the difference between managing money and creating wealth.
Consider the foreign-exchange market.
The Governor is understandably interested in narrowing the gap between the official and parallel rates.
A smaller gap may indicate that foreign exchange is being allocated more efficiently and that confidence in the formal market is improving.
Good.
But suppose the two rates finally converge. What exactly has Ethiopia achieved?
It will have one price for the dollar instead of two.
A useful improvement. But the country will still need dollars to import machinery, to buy fuel, to purchase medicines, to obtain industrial inputs. And those dollars must ultimately come from exports, remittances, investment or borrowing.
A unified exchange rate does not automatically create export earnings. It merely improves the system through which foreign exchange is priced and exchanged.
The Governor also speaks of stronger banks, consolidation, financial inclusion and modern capital markets.
These are respectable ambitions. But strong banks and a strong economy are not necessarily the same thing.
A bank can be profitable while its customers struggle. It can maintain excellent capital ratios while declining to finance small enterprises. It can expand digital payments while farmers remain unable to obtain affordable investment credit. Indeed, a country can become very sophisticated at moving money around without becoming particularly good at producing anything.
The financial sector celebrates transactions. The productive economy needs transformation.
The distinction is fundamental. If the National Bank wants to demonstrate the developmental value of financial reform, it should tell us something more interesting than how many banks have become stronger.
How much additional credit has reached manufacturing? How much has financed agricultural processing? How many small enterprises have obtained investment loans? How much long-term productive investment has been made possible by the new financial arrangements?
These questions are harder to answer. They are also more useful.
There is something else worth examining.
The National Bank Governor has become increasingly prominent in Ethiopia’s economic conversation. We hear about inflation targets, foreign-exchange reserves, banking modernization, financial inclusion and capital markets.
The Governor appears to be explaining not merely monetary policy but the direction of economic reform itself. Perhaps this reflects a welcome effort to communicate more openly.
Central-bank transparency is important. But visibility can also become misplaced.
A central banker should explain what monetary policy is doing, why it is doing it and what risks remain. He should not become the principal public salesman for national prosperity.
That is not his mandate.
Nor should monetary indicators become substitutes for evidence of economic development.
When a central bank celebrates lower inflation, it should also acknowledge that lower inflation does not restore lost purchasing power.
When it celebrates improved foreign-exchange conditions, it should explain that exchange-rate stability does not create export industries.
When it celebrates stronger banks, it should recognize that financial strength does not guarantee productive lending.
A little less triumph would make the announcements more credible.
Ethiopia has undertaken far-reaching monetary reforms. Some were necessary to address longstanding economic imbalances. Others may eventually prove beneficial, provided they deliver results beyond improved financial indicators. Still others, as I have argued before, were questionable in their design, timing and implementation, particularly given their consequences for ordinary Ethiopians and domestic enterprises. All deserve careful scrutiny, not premature celebration.
There is no reason to dismiss improvements simply because they are incomplete. But there is equally no reason to confuse intermediate indicators with final results.
A central bank’s success should be measured by monetary and financial stability, not by its ability to persuade citizens that stabilization is prosperity.
And even those achievements must be durable. One month of lower inflation is not permanent price stability.
A narrower exchange-rate premium is not proof that foreign-exchange shortages have disappeared.
A stronger banking system is not evidence that productive investment has accelerated.
These are beginnings. Not conclusions.
The Governor would do the country a greater service by communicating the limits of his achievements as clearly as the achievements themselves.
There is no shame in saying: We can help stabilize prices, but we cannot restore household incomes. We can improve the foreign-exchange market, but we cannot create exporters. We can supervise banks, but we cannot force them to make every productive investment. We can help establish the financial conditions for growth, but we cannot deliver growth on our own.
Such statements would not diminish the National Bank. They would demonstrate institutional maturity.
One day, perhaps soon, the Governor may stand before the public and announce that inflation has reached single digits.
The exchange-rate gap may be smaller. The banks may be healthier. The financial system may be more sophisticated.
All useful achievements.
But the Ethiopian farmer will still need a market. The manufacturer will still need machinery and customers. The young graduate will still need a job. And the family will still need an income sufficient to meet the cost of living.
None of these problems can be solved by the National Bank alone. That is precisely why the governor’s growing visibility deserves some restraint.
The National Bank is responsible for the monetary conditions under which prosperity may become possible. It is not responsible for manufacturing prosperity itself.
The governor should be congratulated when he does his job well. But he should not be mistaken for the economy. And perhaps the next time the National Bank announces another impressive improvement in its indicators, Ethiopians might politely ask one question:
Very good, Governor. But what exactly are we celebrating?
Editor’s Note: The opinion expressed in this article is that of the author and does not necessarily reflect the position of Ethiopia Today.