Opinion Piece By: Kebour Ghenna
Ethiopia Today (Addis Ababa), July 15, 2025:- The Ministry of Finance has a new trick up its sleeve. It’s not a tax increase, exactly. But it feels like one.
It’s not a wealth confiscation, exactly. But the effect is similar. It’s not even called austerity. But it smells like belt-tightening, handed down not from the heavens but from the IMF boardroom in Washington, D.C.
A new Bright Idea
The ministry says this is about cash flow. They want smoother revenue collection. No more year-end scramble. Instead of letting businesses pay their taxes at the end of the year, based on their real profits, they should pay 25% of last year’s taxes every quarter. That’s right. Your business may be bleeding this year, but if it bled less last year, you owe.
Pay up.
No negotiation. No sympathy. No cash? Go borrow… at 15% interest… if anyone will lend to you.
The Cash-Hungry State
The logic, we’re told, is elegant: the government needs money throughout the year to “deliver services.” But the money only trickles in at the end of the year. Why not “smooth the cash flow,” they say? Why not make businesses behave more like ATMs?
And it’s true, the government has pledged not to borrow from its central bank. No more easy money. A win, they say, for discipline. For macroeconomic integrity.
But discipline for whom?
Certainly not for the bureaucracies still growing fat, the wars still being fought, or the lavish benefits given to senior government officials.
No, discipline is for the private sector; the shopkeepers, manufacturers, exporters, and mid-sized businesses already struggling to survive with a currency that buys less by the week.
When Policy Becomes Punishment
If this all feels like punishment for doing business, it’s because it is. In a country where:
• Seasonal cash flows rule the real economy,
• Foreign exchange is hard to come by,
• Inflation eats margins before profits even materialize,
• And banks are told to lend less (not more)…
…a policy like this doesn’t collect revenue… it kills it.
It squeezes working capital. It forces layoffs. It delays supplier payments. It nudges the struggling entrepreneur into the warm embrace of the grey market. And it turns honest taxpayers into late payers, or worse, non-payers.
The government says it’s doing this to avoid borrowing from itself. That’s noble. But if the choice is between a state borrowing from its central bank and a state forcing early taxes on the private sector, which one damages growth more?
Which one risks turning a fragile recovery into a recession?
There’s always a better way.
Let’s try something wild: tax people based on what they earn, when they earn it.
If the government is desperate for predictable revenue, it can offer incentives for early payment… discounts, access to credit, public recognition.
It can introduce a tiered approach, starting with big, predictable taxpayers… banks, telecoms, and large retail chains?
It could invest in digital reporting, streamline tax filings, and strengthen enforcement for large firms that do dodge taxes.
And while we’re at it, maybe someone should audit the expense accounts of top officials. Cut a few luxury SUVs. Cancel a meeting or two in Dubai. You’d be amazed what that would cover.
The Real Price of Austerity
What we have instead is austerity in disguise. And like all good illusions, it has a message: “You, small business owner, shall carry the burden. You shall pay the state before you pay yourself. And you shall thank us for the opportunity.”
The argument recognizes a real fiscal coordination problem, but the solution risks hurting the very businesses the government relies on for revenue. It addresses symptoms, not causes, and shifts the adjustment burden disproportionately to the private sector, especially SMEs, without creating the conditions for higher productivity or compliance.